I don't remember much about the Matthews story, so I guess I'll have to reappraise it.

For me the worst book is THE KEY OF THE KEPLIAN. I think McConchie did an awful job with the story.
I never finished the book. It's a rare, bad book when I can't finish the read at least once.

Mary Schaub does an okay job with the material. I have no complaints about her writing. But the
most Andre Norton-like author (in my opinion) is Pauline Griffin. It's a pity they took REDLINE
THE STARS away from her to give to some guy who will appeal to a "younger" audience. At least,
that's what I've been told -- don't know if it's true.

Probably not much hope for TIME TRADERS, either.

It's a pity when Andre Norton titles have to be farmed out to people who won't even try to write
like Andre Norton.

Michael
------------------
The Witch World Page