Posted: November 24, 1998 at 14:34:30: by Steve S
: Also if Frodo had just cast the ring into the Bay of Belfalast or whatever, how could it have been recovered?? certainly no fish or any marine life could have weilded it, right? Or wrong?I would think only sentient creatures could wield the ring. The list would include: men, elves, dwarves, orcs, trolls, ents, Maiar (Sauron, Gandalf, Sauruman, balrogs, Osse, etc.), and Valar (the 'gods'). As already stated, Osse could find the ring if pitched into the seas. But also, as was shown with the ring's history to that point, just losing it very thoroughly would not mean losing it forever. SOMEHOW it would turn up. Whether a fish swallowed it that was caught by a fisherman, or Osse found it, or the currents just pushed it along until it was washed up on the shore of Far Harad to be found. Also, even if it was lost forever, as long as it existed Sauron had all the advantage he needed to win the war. It wasn't enough to keep Sauron from getting it. It had to be destroyed. For those of you celebrating it this week (myself included), have a great Thanksgiving. Take some time to think of what you have to be thankful for & then remember to whom you are thankful. -Steve S.
|