White Council Forum Archive 11 Index

White Council: The Tolkien Forum archive_11

• Just suppose... - Steve S. on February 23, 1999 at 16:54:15: (12)
  • Re: Just suppose... Padster 17:39:02 2/24/99 (3)
    • Re: Just suppose... Al 08:17:09 2/25/99 (2)
      • Re: Just suppose... Padster 12:25:37 2/25/99 (1)
        • Re: Just suppose... Al 06:19:59 2/26/99 (0)
  • Re: Just suppose... Ryan Williams 17:21:17 2/23/99 (7)
    • Re: Just suppose... Turgon 17:36:49 2/23/99 (6)
      • Re: Just suppose... Jon 15:10:22 2/24/99 (5)
        • Re: Just suppose... Turgon 20:16:44 2/24/99 (4)
          • Re: Just suppose... Jon 20:34:16 2/24/99 (3)
            • Re: Just suppose... Ian 23:25:15 2/24/99 (2)
              • Re: Just suppose... Jon 14:57:57 2/25/99 (0)
              • Re: Just suppose... Jon 14:57:49 2/25/99 (0)
• How many Rings of Power? - asfaloth on February 23, 1999 at 16:43:59: (1)
  • Re: How many Rings of Power? Michael Martinez 04:03:02 2/24/99 (0)
• Pipeweed - Filby on February 23, 1999 at 12:10:34: (3)
  • Re: Pipeweed Steve S 16:46:12 2/23/99 (2)
    • Re: Pipeweed Davewise 02:23:26 2/27/99 (1)
      • Pipeweed and Gandalf Jon 19:40:37 3/01/99 (0)
• Frodo the only true hero????? - thorongil on February 23, 1999 at 10:38:20: (15)
  • Counterpoint... Artanaro 17:42:51 2/23/99 (14)
    • Re: Counterpoint... Padster 02:37:32 2/24/99 (4)
      • Re: Counterpoint... Al 03:44:10 2/28/99 (3)
        • Re: Counterpoint... Padster 05:43:52 2/28/99 (2)
          • Re: Counterpoint... Al 04:01:12 3/01/99 (1)
            • Re: Counterpoint... Padster 13:57:34 3/02/99 (0)
    • Re: Counterpoint... Hama 18:05:37 2/23/99 (8)
      • Re: Counterpoint... Hama 18:26:26 2/23/99 (1)
        • Re: Counterpoint... Hama 00:13:11 2/24/99 (0)
      • Re: Counterpoint... Hama 18:06:47 2/23/99 (5)
        • Re: Counterpoint... Ryan Williams 22:43:55 2/23/99 (4)
          • Re: Counterpoint... Al 04:09:13 2/28/99 (0)
          • Re: Counterpoint... Jon 20:41:28 2/24/99 (2)
            • Re: Counterpoint... Hama 21:07:24 2/26/99 (1)
              • Re: Counterpoint... Hama 21:20:49 2/26/99 (0)
• elf queen in "Lord of the Rings" - sprite on February 22, 1999 at 18:48:15: (4)
  • Re: elf queen in "Lord of the Rings" Padster 19:52:41 2/22/99 (1)
    • Re: elf queen in "Lord of the Rings" Michael Martinez 04:58:56 2/23/99 (0)
  • Re: elf queen in "Lord of the Rings" Beorn 19:18:53 2/22/99 (0)
  • Re: elf queen in "Lord of the Rings" Aielman 18:55:41 2/22/99 (0)
• Message Board Updated - The Administrators on February 22, 1999 at 04:39:29: (0)
• Martinez opinion plz - Ryan Williams on February 21, 1999 at 22:11:33: (16)
  • A Witch King Prophecy Opinion (was Re: Martinez opinion plz) Michael Martinez 05:22:58 2/22/99 (15)
    • Witch King: a match for Gandalf? HA Jon 17:25:23 2/22/99 (14)
      • Re: Witch King: a match for Gandalf? PROBABLY!!! Padster 19:47:54 2/22/99 (1)
        • Re: Witch King: a match for Gandalf? PROBABLY!!! Ryan Williams 20:04:25 2/22/99 (0)
      • Re: Witch King: a match for Gandalf? PROBABLY!!! Padster 19:46:59 2/22/99 (0)
      • Re: Witch King: a match for Gandalf? HA Witch-King 18:12:34 2/22/99 (10)
        • Re: Witch King: a match for Gandalf? HA Ryan Williams 18:52:07 2/22/99 (9)
          • Re: Witch King: a match for Gandalf? HA Witch-King 18:59:01 2/22/99 (8)
            • Re: Witch King: a match for Gandalf? HA Ryan Williams 19:17:06 2/22/99 (7)
              • Happy Mexican Hat Dance Aielman 19:23:00 2/22/99 (6)
                • Re: Happy Mexican Hat Dance null 19:38:58 2/22/99 (5)
                  • Re: Happy Mexican Hat Dance Witch-King 21:52:56 2/22/99 (4)
                    • Re: Happy Mexican Hat Dance Randy Whitaker 21:53:15 2/24/99 (0)
                    • What about Eowyn Jon 22:07:55 2/23/99 (0)
                    • Re: WitchKing vs Gandalf Scarmig 07:33:25 2/23/99 (0)
                    • Re: Gandalf vs Witch-King Ryan Williams 07:32:43 2/23/99 (0)
• Apologies to Martinez - Aielman on February 21, 1999 at 18:13:49: (1)
  • Re: Apologies to Martinez Michael Martinez 22:05:56 2/21/99 (0)
• The Genders of the Valar... - Artanaro on February 21, 1999 at 17:52:26: (6)
  • Re: The Genders of the Valar... Jon 19:46:42 2/21/99 (5)
    • Re: The Genders of the Valar... Michael Martinez 22:18:35 2/21/99 (4)
      • Re: The Genders of the Valar... Martin Read 04:08:00 2/24/99 (3)
        • Re: The Genders of the Valar... Ian 23:33:39 2/24/99 (1)
          • Re: The Genders of the Valar... Martin Read 04:05:57 2/25/99 (0)
        • Re: The Genders of the Valar... Ian 23:29:29 2/24/99 (0)
• Flaming on this Message Board - Michael Martinez on February 21, 1999 at 17:11:33: (2)
  • Re: Flaming on this Message Board Gollum 18:52:16 2/21/99 (1)
    • The Administrators Xylonite 21:00:55 2/21/99 (0)
• Letters of Tolkien - Me on February 20, 1999 at 18:50:18: (2)
  • Re: Letters of Tolkien Michael Martinez 17:14:04 2/21/99 (1)
    • Re: Letters of Tolkien Voronwe 23:00:17 2/24/99 (0)
• Survey - Aielman on February 20, 1999 at 12:01:20: (28)
  • Re: Survey Steve S. 15:58:50 2/22/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Michael Martinez 22:21:57 2/21/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Randy Whitaker 16:35:23 2/21/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Akhronath 14:23:41 2/21/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Kadri 12:12:59 2/21/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Ryan Williams 01:05:38 2/21/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Artanaro 21:55:40 2/20/99 (19)
    • Frodo the only selfless hero??????????? Ryan Williams 13:33:35 2/21/99 (0)
    • Frodo the only selfless hero? What about Gandalf? Jon 12:57:40 2/21/99 (17)
      • Frodo, the true hero... Artarnaro 17:20:49 2/21/99 (16)
        • Re: Frodo, the true hero... Akhronath 19:55:30 2/21/99 (0)
        • Re: Frodo, the true hero... Jon 19:41:14 2/21/99 (0)
        • Re: Frodo, the true hero... Gollum 18:23:44 2/21/99 (13)
          • Re: Frodo, the true hero... HAMA 00:28:45 2/23/99 (12)
            • A MUSICAL.................!(?) Denver 03:26:28 2/23/99 (11)
              • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) HAMA 11:16:25 2/23/99 (10)
                • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Steve S. 12:35:28 2/25/99 (0)
                • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Padster 13:02:23 2/23/99 (8)
                  • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Hama 14:52:25 2/23/99 (0)
                  • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Hama 14:52:18 2/23/99 (6)
                    • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Aielman 22:49:47 2/23/99 (5)
                      • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Hama 00:28:25 2/24/99 (4)
                        • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Scarmig 07:19:00 2/24/99 (0)
                        • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Padster 02:22:09 2/24/99 (2)
                          • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Voronwe 15:40:40 2/24/99 (1)
                            • Re: A MUSICAL.................!(?) Hama 01:03:11 2/25/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Witch-King 21:40:01 2/20/99 (0)
  • Re: Survey Jon 16:53:57 2/20/99 (0)
• Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? - Witch-King on February 20, 1999 at 00:27:39: (22)
  • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Ryan Williams 01:15:02 2/20/99 (21)
    • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Witch-King 06:15:13 2/20/99 (20)
      • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Ryan Williams 11:06:39 2/20/99 (19)
        • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Jon 17:03:59 2/20/99 (18)
          • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Witch-King 21:19:00 2/20/99 (17)
            • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Artanaro 21:41:15 2/20/99 (16)
              • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Witch-King 22:30:24 2/20/99 (15)
                • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Ryan Williams 00:16:50 2/21/99 (14)
                  • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Whitch-King 00:38:52 2/21/99 (13)
                    • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Ryan Williams 00:57:47 2/21/99 (12)
                      • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Witch-King 01:19:59 2/21/99 (11)
                        • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Padster 01:40:15 2/21/99 (10)
                          • Re: Is it just me, or did the Nazgul do next to nothing? Ryan Williams 11:50:19 2/21/99 (9)
                            • Okay, okay, you beat me, but I can still try to save my point from utter death. Whitch-King 14:09:04 2/21/99 (8)
                              • Re: Okay, okay, you beat me, but I can still try to save my point from utter death. Ryan Williams 15:02:16 2/21/99 (7)
                                • Re: Okay, okay, you beat me, but I can still try to save my point from utter death. Witch-King 15:54:04 2/21/99 (6)
                                  • Re: Okay, okay, you beat me, but I can still try to save my point from utter death. Ryan Williams 16:18:02 2/21/99 (5)
                                    • Re: Point Akhronath 16:22:43 2/21/99 (4)
                                      • Re: Point Witch-King 20:18:01 2/21/99 (2)
                                        • Re: Point Ryan Williams 21:14:36 2/21/99 (0)
                                        • Re: Point Ryan Williams 21:14:10 2/21/99 (0)
                                      • Re: Point Aielman 16:25:35 2/21/99 (0)
• Saruman-revisited - asfaloth on February 19, 1999 at 17:44:22: (1)
  • Re: Saruman-revisited asfaloth 16:33:14 2/23/99 (0)
• Why not forge another? - Ryan Williams on February 19, 1999 at 16:35:01: (4)
  • Re: Why not forge another? Michael Martinez 13:28:58 2/20/99 (0)
  • Re: Why not forge another? asfaloth 17:34:49 2/19/99 (2)
    • Re: Why not forge another? Jon 22:34:13 2/19/99 (1)
      • Re: Why not forge another? Michael Martinez 13:35:58 2/20/99 (0)
• How does Middle Earth relate to the present day? - thorongil on February 19, 1999 at 09:59:18: (1)
  • Re: How does Middle Earth relate to the present day? Michael Martinez 13:27:25 2/20/99 (0)
• Confusion about Saruman - Asfaloth on February 18, 1999 at 14:14:33: (4)
  • Re: Confusion about Saruman Padster 20:08:47 2/18/99 (2)
    • Re: Confusion about Saruman Mandos 12:47:07 2/19/99 (0)
    • Re: Confusion about Saruman Ryan Williams 22:35:59 2/18/99 (0)
  • Re: Confusion about Saruman Padster 20:06:31 2/18/99 (0)
• Finrod and Minis Tirith - Scarmig on February 18, 1999 at 09:11:53: (2)
  • Re: Finrod and Minis Tirith Olorin 10:31:07 2/18/99 (1)
    • Re: Finrod and Minis Tirith Scarmig 11:21:44 2/18/99 (0)
• Book Review? - Filby on February 17, 1999 at 15:18:49: (2)
  • Re: Book Review? Michael Martinez 13:18:46 2/20/99 (1)
    • Re: Book Review? Filby 15:49:16 2/22/99 (0)
• Essence and enchanted items - Scarmig on February 17, 1999 at 10:34:59: (9)
  • Re: Essence and enchanted items Ryan Williams 17:46:19 2/17/99 (3)
    • Re: Comparative Essence-loss Asfaloth 12:25:25 2/18/99 (0)
    • Re: Essence and enchanted items Asfaloth 12:20:47 2/18/99 (1)
      • Re: Essence and enchanted items Scarmig 10:35:12 2/19/99 (0)
  • Actually.. null 13:05:08 2/17/99 (4)
    • Re: Actually.. Padster 12:27:29 2/18/99 (2)
      • That not what I meant.. null 13:33:22 2/19/99 (1)
        • Re: That not what I meant.. Padster 13:47:44 2/19/99 (0)
    • Morgoth Jon 18:05:54 2/17/99 (0)
• I was reading a book on Tolkien... - Jon on February 16, 1999 at 21:13:38: (7)
  • Re: I was reading a book on Tolkien... Michael Martinez 13:10:39 2/20/99 (0)
  • Re: I was reading a book on Tolkien... Finrod 14:25:47 2/17/99 (5)
    • Re: I was reading a book on Tolkien... Ryan Williams 18:52:46 2/17/99 (4)
      • Re: I was reading a book on Tolkien... Padster 12:23:02 2/18/99 (2)
        • Re: I was reading a book on Tolkien... Ryan Williams 22:42:32 2/18/99 (1)
          • Gandalf's Mind Powers (was Re: I was reading a book on Tolkien...) Michael Martinez 13:15:13 2/20/99 (0)
      • Re: I was reading a book on Tolkien... Asfaloth 12:00:17 2/18/99 (0)
• Elven Rings - Ryan Williams on February 16, 1999 at 20:51:19: (22)
  • The Three Did Not Confer Invisibility (was Re: Elven Rings) Michael Martinez 12:52:23 2/20/99 (0)
  • Re: Elven Rings Sean 08:45:07 2/17/99 (20)
    • Excuse me if I'm wrong, but... null 13:13:34 2/17/99 (19)
      • Re: Excuse me if I'm wrong, but... Aielman 17:43:31 2/17/99 (18)
        • Re: Excuse me if I'm wrong, but... Cyberlock 18:29:06 2/17/99 (17)
          • Re: Excuse me if I'm wrong, but... Mandos 12:53:54 2/19/99 (1)
            • Barrow Wights (was Re: Excuse me if I'm wrong, but...) Michael Martinez 13:00:34 2/20/99 (0)
          • Re:I ain't wrong Martin Read 04:13:02 2/18/99 (14)
            • Re:I ain't wrong Aielman 07:39:32 2/18/99 (13)
              • Re:I ain't wrong Martin Read 11:13:16 2/18/99 (12)
                • Re:I ain't wrong Aielman 22:20:51 2/18/99 (11)
                  • Re:I ain't wrong Martin Read 04:55:36 2/19/99 (10)
                    • Re:I ain't wrong Aielman 07:45:54 2/19/99 (9)
                      • Re:Carn Dum Martin Read 08:31:30 2/19/99 (8)
                        • Re:Carn Dum Padster 11:44:30 2/19/99 (7)
                          • Re:Carn Dum Martin Read 07:46:15 2/24/99 (1)
                            • Re:Carn Dum Martin Read 11:20:15 2/24/99 (0)
                          • Tyrn Gorthad's mounds (was Re:Carn Dum) Michael Martinez 13:08:20 2/20/99 (0)
                          • Re:Carn Dum Scarmig 13:27:56 2/19/99 (3)
                            • Re:Carn Dum Padster 13:57:33 2/19/99 (1)
                              • Re:Carn Dum scarmig 14:57:55 2/19/99 (0)
                            • Re:Carn Dum Padster 13:56:36 2/19/99 (0)
• Nine Riders - Aielman on February 16, 1999 at 18:13:49: (1)
  • Re: Nine Riders Akhronath 22:16:26 2/16/99 (0)
• Radagast - Beorn on February 16, 1999 at 16:23:26: (3)
  • Re: Radagast Scarmig 09:26:33 2/17/99 (2)
    • Re: Radagast Aielman 18:55:40 2/17/99 (1)
      • Re: Radagast Michael Martinez 12:49:55 2/20/99 (0)
• Gandalfs Ring - Aielman on February 15, 1999 at 21:57:56: (8)
  • Re: Gandalfs Ring Michael Martinez 02:21:54 2/16/99 (7)
    • Re: Gandalfs Ring Padster 11:44:06 2/16/99 (6)
      • Re: Gandalfs Ring Michael Martinez 16:54:07 2/21/99 (0)
      • Re: Reply to Padster about Gandalf/Saruman asfaloth 12:47:38 2/18/99 (4)
        • Battles of Will (was Re: Reply to Padster about Gandalf/Saruman) Michael Martinez 16:56:15 2/21/99 (0)
        • Re: Reply to Padster about Gandalf/Saruman Padster 13:52:57 2/18/99 (2)
          • Gandalf's Hope (was Re: Reply to Padster about Gandalf/Saruman) Michael Martinez 17:03:43 2/21/99 (0)
          • Re: Reply to Padster about Gandalf/Saruman Ryan Williams 22:26:37 2/18/99 (0)
• Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? - Artanaro on February 14, 1999 at 21:22:31: (9)
  • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Martin Read 04:39:50 2/15/99 (8)
    • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Artanaro 10:39:39 2/15/99 (5)
      • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Ian 22:55:49 2/15/99 (4)
        • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Michael Martinez 02:25:22 2/16/99 (3)
          • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Martin Read 04:23:48 2/16/99 (2)
            • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Michael Martinez 16:48:41 2/21/99 (1)
              • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Martin Read 05:32:51 2/22/99 (0)
    • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Jon 10:28:24 2/15/99 (1)
      • Re: Beren/Luthien,Aragorn/Arwen...Reincarnation? Michael Martinez 02:27:54 2/16/99 (0)
• Tolkien relative Victorian actor? - Carol Maltby on February 14, 1999 at 19:32:52: (0)
• Selob - Beorn on February 13, 1999 at 22:52:37: (4)
  • Re: Selob Martin Read 04:33:32 2/15/99 (0)
  • Re: Selob Michael Martinez 20:24:21 2/14/99 (0)
  • Re: Selob Padster 06:39:48 2/14/99 (1)
    • physical form Mordan 07:46:33 2/17/99 (0)