Posted: September 17, 1999 at 09:40:15: by Martin Read
: I think that David Eddings and Robert Jordan are both excellent (American) authors. Eddings character interaction is a true joy to read and Jordan approaches Tolkien in sure scope of his project (the size history and dynamics af a complex and many faceted land). Both extremely good authors (though Eddings is more prolific in that he has two "universes" Jordon continues his Wheel of Time series . 8th book and all 500+ pages) In fact Jordan is being lauded as the American Tolkien. One interesting tidbit about Jordan is he wrote many of the best Conan novels which is a big departure from The Wheel of Time.: Eddings character interaction is one of the bet ive read... specifically in the Sparhawk novels. He also has a rich land fully populated with myth, legend and a history that is more then one dimensional. : As to the Dragonlance novels. They had a strong plot (Contrary to what many believe. That series was actually Roleplayed out then written so that Wies and Hickman more or less had that series handed to them.) However the writing "style" reminded me of what I call "pulp fantasy". In other words it wasnt very well written and I believe the Death Gate series reafirms that. One example that comes to mind is the need to bring Palantir "Fizban" into one of the novels and thus further erode any individuality that series may have had. Reminded me of a Hollywood stunt cameo to increase publicity and revenue for a bad movie. Eddings has a unique place in the history of my reading matter. He is the only author I have physically consigned to the rubbish bin (trash can). I think it was the first of the Belgariad ? novels, I read about 50 pages or so, decided it was puerile drivel and threw it away.
| 
