White Council Forum Archive 39 Index

White Council: The Tolkien Forum archive_39

• What Is Literature? - Goodgulf on January 17, 2000 at 11:59:07: (15)
  • Re: What Is Literature? shadowfax 07:31:26 1/18/2000 (2)
    • Re: What Is Literature? Sean 11:03:44 1/19/2000 (0)
    • Re: What Is Literature? Goodgulf 22:07:06 1/18/2000 (0)
  • Re: What Is Literature? Olorin 00:38:12 1/18/2000 (0)
  • Re: What Is Literature? Jim Gregors 22:51:35 1/17/2000 (1)
    • Re: What Is Literature? Goodgulf 01:41:26 1/18/2000 (0)
  • Re: What Is Literature? Heorrenda 14:20:35 1/17/2000 (8)
    • Re: What Is Literature? Goodgulf 16:23:45 1/17/2000 (7)
      • Re: What Is Literature? David Freitag 16:42:22 1/17/2000 (6)
        • Re: What Is Literature? Martin Read 09:49:07 1/18/2000 (5)
          • Re: What Is Literature? RobRoy 11:17:49 1/18/2000 (4)
            • Re: What Is Literature? Goodgulf 22:22:41 1/18/2000 (0)
            • Re: What Is Literature? Wibstap 16:02:26 1/18/2000 (2)
              • Re: What Is Literature? RobRoy 10:38:02 1/19/2000 (0)
              • Re: What Is Literature? Goodgulf 22:41:47 1/18/2000 (0)
• Elves and Ears - Wibstap on January 17, 2000 at 09:32:51: (8)
  • On Tolkien's Elves: Appearance, Ears, Beards, and more (was Re: Elves and Ears) Michael Martinez 21:39:02 1/18/2000 (2)
    • Re: On Tolkien's Elves: Appearance, Ears, Beards, and more (was Re: Elves and Ears) Tar-Elenion 23:41:16 1/18/2000 (0)
    • Re: On Tolkien's Elves: Appearance, Ears, Beards, and more (was Re: Elves and Ears) Goodgulf 23:16:19 1/18/2000 (0)
  • Re: Elves and Ears Goodgulf 12:18:19 1/17/2000 (4)
    • Re: Elves and Ears Wibstap 21:53:24 1/17/2000 (3)
      • Re: Elves and Ears Olorin 00:43:31 1/18/2000 (2)
        • Re: Elves and Ears Tar-Elenion 01:16:41 1/18/2000 (1)
          • Re: Elves and Ears Wibstap 10:45:14 1/18/2000 (0)
• Godorian Elite Troops - Martin Read on January 17, 2000 at 09:17:46: (7)
  • Re: Godorian Elite Troops Tar-Elenion 00:30:44 1/18/2000 (6)
    • Re: Godorian Elite Troops Tar-Elenion 01:05:17 1/18/2000 (5)
      • Re: Gondorian Elite Troops Martin Read 04:12:02 1/18/2000 (4)
        • Re: Gondorian Elite Troops Michael Martinez 20:02:41 1/18/2000 (3)
          • Re: Gondorian Elite Troops Martin Read 08:41:29 1/19/2000 (0)
          • Re: Gondorian Elite Troops Tar-Elenion 22:56:05 1/18/2000 (1)
            • Re: Gondorian Elite Troops Michael Martinez 23:11:56 1/18/2000 (0)
• Fui - GothmoG on January 17, 2000 at 01:34:34: (4)
  • Re: Fui to wibstap GothmoG 22:30:42 1/17/2000 (1)
    • Re: Fui to wibstap Jim Gregors 22:58:19 1/17/2000 (0)
  • Re: Fui Wibstap 09:21:16 1/17/2000 (1)
    • Re: Fui Aelmer 21:27:55 1/18/2000 (0)
• thuringwethil - GothmoG on January 17, 2000 at 01:32:27: (2)
  • Re: thuringwethil Samug the Magnificent 06:44:36 1/17/2000 (1)
    • Re: thuringwethil Jim Gregors 22:17:19 1/17/2000 (0)
• Farmer Giles of Ham - Wibstap on January 16, 2000 at 16:41:58: (0)
• Archiving problems - Michael Martinez on January 16, 2000 at 15:19:49: (0)
• Thingol's heir - Stephen Geard on January 15, 2000 at 19:33:00: (13)
  • Re: Thingol's heir Russ 12:21:13 1/17/2000 (0)
  • Re: Thingol's heir Russ 12:20:40 1/17/2000 (0)
  • Re: Thingol's heir Tar-Elenion 22:40:06 1/15/2000 (10)
    • Re: Thingol's heir Russ 12:43:34 1/17/2000 (0)
    • Re: Thingol's heir Michael Martinez 16:28:12 1/16/2000 (8)
      • Re: Thingol's heir Tar-Elenion 19:11:48 1/16/2000 (7)
        • Re: Thingol's heir Martin Read 08:41:40 1/17/2000 (6)
          • Re: Thingol's heir Heorrenda 15:42:23 1/17/2000 (5)
            • Re: Thingol's heir Meneldur 10:25:46 1/18/2000 (4)
              • Re: Thingol's heir Michael Martinez 22:26:15 1/18/2000 (3)
                • Dual monarchical traditions and inheritance Martin Read 08:55:35 1/19/2000 (0)
                • Sindarin dialects was: Re: Thingol's heir Tar-Elenion 01:02:12 1/19/2000 (0)
                • Re: Thingol's heir Tar-Elenion 00:45:11 1/19/2000 (0)
• Tolkien-related Web Page - Wibstap on January 15, 2000 at 13:29:52: (1)
  • Re: Tolkien-related Web Page Meneldur 11:42:45 1/16/2000 (0)
• Tolkien-related Web Page - Wibstap on January 15, 2000 at 13:28:50: (0)
• Message Board Updated - The Administrators on January 15, 2000 at 11:45:36: (0)
• Elves - Wibstap on January 15, 2000 at 10:14:56: (2)
  • Re: Elves Michael Martinez 16:29:17 1/16/2000 (0)
  • Re: Elves Heorrenda 14:15:55 1/15/2000 (0)
• Oh no, not again...... - Wibstap on January 15, 2000 at 10:05:11: (0)
• On Dior Thingol's Heir - Michael Martinez on January 14, 2000 at 17:04:24: (31)
  • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Russ 17:53:38 1/15/2000 (2)
    • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 15:24:50 1/16/2000 (1)
      • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Russ 10:20:11 1/17/2000 (0)
  • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Tar-Elenion 04:47:02 1/15/2000 (18)
    • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 15:38:03 1/16/2000 (5)
      • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Tar-Elenion 18:38:31 1/16/2000 (2)
        • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 03:21:52 1/17/2000 (1)
          • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Tar-Elenion 15:19:32 1/17/2000 (0)
      • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Tar-Elenion 18:25:25 1/16/2000 (1)
        • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 03:29:42 1/17/2000 (0)
    • Kingship of the Noldor Jim Gregors 10:41:00 1/15/2000 (11)
      • Re: Kingship of the Noldor Tar-Elenion 19:21:24 1/15/2000 (10)
        • Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Jim Gregors 23:15:23 1/16/2000 (8)
          • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Russ 14:32:04 1/17/2000 (2)
            • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Jim Gregors 22:36:45 1/17/2000 (1)
              • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Russ 10:33:31 1/18/2000 (0)
          • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Michael Martinez 03:37:24 1/17/2000 (2)
            • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Tar-Elenion 18:50:41 1/17/2000 (1)
              • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Michael Martinez 20:18:14 1/18/2000 (0)
          • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Tar-Elenion 00:09:38 1/17/2000 (1)
            • Re: Female Inheritance (prior post came out poorly) Heorrenda 01:21:38 1/17/2000 (0)
        • Female Inheritance Jim Gregors 23:09:39 1/16/2000 (0)
  • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir DAVID 23:35:20 1/14/2000 (6)
    • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Tar-Elenion 15:44:12 1/17/2000 (0)
    • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 15:46:49 1/16/2000 (4)
      • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Russ 10:35:24 1/17/2000 (3)
        • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 20:25:27 1/18/2000 (2)
          • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Tar-Elenion 23:27:20 1/18/2000 (1)
            • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 03:08:53 1/19/2000 (0)
  • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Gilgach son of Rumil 21:59:44 1/14/2000 (1)
    • Re: On Dior Thingol's Heir Michael Martinez 15:47:59 1/16/2000 (0)
• Orcs - Wibstap on January 14, 2000 at 12:18:51: (4)
  • Re: Orcs GothmoG 22:38:24 1/17/2000 (1)
    • Re: Orcs Michael Martinez 03:11:31 1/19/2000 (0)
  • Re: Orcs Jim Gregors 17:32:33 1/14/2000 (0)
  • Re: Orcs Dave C-Q 13:48:44 1/14/2000 (0)
• looking for someone - Isilion Nolendil Eldafuin Laiorë on January 14, 2000 at 09:08:48: (0)
• Dwarves and Dwarfs - Wibstap on January 13, 2000 at 20:26:07: (23)
  • Re: Dwarves and Dwarfs DAVID 21:23:44 1/13/2000 (22)
    • mixed race marriages shadowfax 05:52:26 1/14/2000 (21)
      • Re: mixed race marriages Gilgach son of Rumil 22:06:02 1/14/2000 (1)
        • Re: mixed race marriages shadowfax 08:32:36 1/17/2000 (0)
      • Re: mixed race marriages Dave C-Q 10:17:53 1/14/2000 (18)
        • Re: mixed race marriages Wibstap 11:59:16 1/14/2000 (17)
          • Re: mixed race marriages Dave C-Q 13:13:43 1/14/2000 (16)
            • Re: Hobbits Wibstap 14:51:13 1/14/2000 (15)
              • Re: Hobbits Gilgach son of Rumil 22:09:04 1/14/2000 (14)
                • Re: Hobbits Wibstap 09:36:14 1/15/2000 (0)
                • Re: Hobbits Wibstap 09:35:47 1/15/2000 (12)
                  • Re: Hobbits Heorrenda 16:07:54 1/15/2000 (11)
                    • Re: Hobbits Wibstap 18:10:41 1/15/2000 (10)
                      • Re: Hobbits Heorrenda 19:01:16 1/15/2000 (9)
                        • Re: Druedain Gildor 19:55:08 1/15/2000 (8)
                          • Re: Druedain Heorrenda 21:25:02 1/15/2000 (7)
                            • Re: Druedain Wibstap 22:36:09 1/15/2000 (5)
                              • Re: Druedain Heorrenda 01:52:15 1/16/2000 (4)
                                • Re: Evolution Wibstap 16:56:01 1/16/2000 (3)
                                  • Re: Evolution Martin Read 10:39:54 1/17/2000 (2)
                                    • Re: Evolution The Lord of the Onion Rings 22:04:48 1/17/2000 (0)
                                    • Re: Evolution The Lord of the Onion Rings 22:04:24 1/17/2000 (0)
                            • Re: Druedain Wibstap 22:35:33 1/15/2000 (0)
• Placement of Middle-earth - Wibstap on January 13, 2000 at 20:10:51: (7)
  • Re: Placement of Middle-earth Dave C-Q 10:26:33 1/14/2000 (1)
    • Re: Placement of Middle-earth Wibstap 12:03:20 1/14/2000 (0)
  • Re: Placement of Middle-earth Gungnir 08:22:57 1/14/2000 (3)
    • Re: Placement of Middle-earth Wibstap 12:01:57 1/14/2000 (2)
      • Re: Placement of Middle-earth Gungnir 12:09:02 1/14/2000 (1)
        • Re: Placement of Middle-earth Wibstap 14:48:58 1/14/2000 (0)
  • Re: Placement of Middle-earth Beren 23:34:06 1/13/2000 (0)
• A thought about Saruman - DAVID on January 13, 2000 at 18:57:16: (4)
  • Re: A thought about Saruman Dave C-Q 10:19:51 1/14/2000 (0)
  • Re: A thought about Saruman Goodgulf 00:38:09 1/14/2000 (2)
    • Re: A thought about Saruman RobRoy 11:31:46 1/14/2000 (1)
      • Re: A thought about Saruman Old Man Willo 11:33:22 1/15/2000 (0)
• trivia answer- Hobbit (TV) - pkirith on January 13, 2000 at 18:20:19: (0)
• For Michael re: the Éothéod in Arnor and the names of the Istari - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:56:28: (6)
  • Re: For Michael re: the Éothéod in Arnor and the names of the Istari Michael Martinez 16:54:54 1/14/2000 (5)
    • Re: For Michael re: the Éothéod in Arnor and the names of the Istari Berembrôg 09:37:09 1/16/2000 (1)
      • Re: For Michael re: the Éothéod in Arnor and the names of the Istari Michael Martinez 15:51:35 1/16/2000 (0)
    • Re: Anglo-Saxon Wizard names Dave C-Q 17:39:44 1/14/2000 (2)
      • Re: Anglo-Saxon Wizard names Jim Gregors 09:55:00 1/15/2000 (0)
      • Re: Anglo-Saxon Wizard names Wibstap 09:44:21 1/15/2000 (0)
• Salique Law in Gondor? - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:54:48: (4)
  • Re: Salique Law in Gondor? Jim Gregors 23:33:40 1/13/2000 (3)
    • Re: Salique Law in Gondor? Michael Martinez 15:59:32 1/16/2000 (2)
      • Succession to the Kingship and the Council of Gondor Jim Gregors 21:45:48 1/17/2000 (0)
      • Succession to the Kingship and the Council of Gondor Jim Gregors 21:45:33 1/17/2000 (0)
• Before and After Tyrn Gorthad - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:52:53: (6)
  • Re: wights Gildor 18:13:08 1/13/2000 (5)
    • Re: wights Erestor 08:23:37 1/15/2000 (0)
    • Re: wights DAVID 16:01:59 1/14/2000 (2)
      • Re: wights Berembrôg 09:42:37 1/16/2000 (0)
      • Re: wights Olorin 03:07:59 1/16/2000 (0)
    • Re: wights Wibstap 12:27:49 1/14/2000 (0)
• Physical traits of the Teleri - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:51:09: (3)
  • Re: Physical traits of the Teleri Gildor 18:10:48 1/13/2000 (2)
    • Re: Physical traits of the Teleri Tar-Elenion 23:07:01 1/13/2000 (1)
      • Re: Physical traits of the Teleri Martin Read 10:19:55 1/14/2000 (0)
• For Michael re: Vanishing Peoples - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:49:53: (3)
  • Re: For Michael re: Vanishing Peoples Michael Martinez 17:23:18 1/14/2000 (2)
    • Re: For Michael re: Vanishing Peoples Berembrôg 09:39:10 1/16/2000 (1)
      • Re: For Michael re: Vanishing Peoples Michael Martinez 16:09:29 1/16/2000 (0)
• Why Ered Luin? - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:48:05: (2)
  • Re: Why Ered Luin? Wibstap 19:45:03 1/13/2000 (1)
    • Re: Why Ered Luin? Michael Martinez 16:34:32 1/16/2000 (0)
• Who were the Axe-men? - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:46:09: (1)
  • Re: Maybe Variags? Gildor 18:06:39 1/13/2000 (0)
• Geography of Middle Earth - Berembrôg on January 13, 2000 at 16:44:58: (2)
  • Re: Geography of Middle Earth Michael Martinez 03:17:59 1/19/2000 (0)
  • Re: Geography of Middle Earth Wibstap 12:32:10 1/14/2000 (0)
• Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History - Michael Martinez on January 13, 2000 at 16:28:26: (13)
  • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History shadowfax 06:22:47 1/17/2000 (2)
    • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History Michael Martinez 20:34:37 1/18/2000 (0)
    • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History shadowfax 06:29:58 1/17/2000 (0)
  • Missing the Point?? RobRoy 11:18:10 1/14/2000 (4)
    • Re: Missing the Point?? Michael Martinez 17:39:01 1/14/2000 (3)
      • Last Comment RobRoy 10:39:13 1/17/2000 (0)
      • Re: Missing the Point?? Jeuda the Dwarf 11:07:20 1/15/2000 (0)
      • A little help. . . Beren 22:31:15 1/14/2000 (0)
  • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History shadowfax 05:45:36 1/14/2000 (4)
    • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History shadowfax 06:27:17 1/17/2000 (3)
      • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History Heorrenda 13:42:25 1/17/2000 (2)
        • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History Michael Martinez 20:38:06 1/18/2000 (0)
        • Re: Learning from Tolkien's decisions about the Eagles, and from History shadowfax 07:42:43 1/18/2000 (0)
• Stone-Giants and Trolls - Wibstap on January 13, 2000 at 12:52:31: (3)
  • Re: Stone-Giants and Trolls Dave C-Q 14:39:05 1/13/2000 (2)
    • Re: Stone-Giants and Trolls shadowfax 16:13:35 1/13/2000 (1)
      • Re: Trolls Gildor 17:58:22 1/13/2000 (0)
• Ents and Huorns - Shadowfax on January 13, 2000 at 11:25:32: (1)
  • Re: Ents and Huorns Wibstap 12:22:37 1/13/2000 (0)