Posted: May 02, 2000 at 15:39:24: by DGG
: : I think we have neglected one thing in our debate about the strengths and weaknesses of Elves through the Ages.
: : The FA elves were much stronger in both physical and magical strength than the elves of the TA. However we have overlooked one thing. A lot (I didn't say all!!) of the elves of the first age were morons. Feanor's oath, the kinslayings, their exile from Aman, the pride of almost all the elvenlords. Even Fingolfin's duel with Morgoth was dumb. Yes it was an EXTREMELY brave thing to do but I believe there was a better place for Fingolfin's bravery.
I disagree about Fingolfin. You are using hindsight, a much easier pair of spectacles than foresight. After all, if all of the elves (and men) of ME logically thought their way through a fight first, and fought only if they knew they could win, then there would have been far less deeds to sing about.
For instance, had the Nazgul slain Eowyn, would you have said, "brave, but stupid."? No. Great deeds are done by beings who take the chances, no matter what the odds. Those who lose, "foolish" those who win? "Heros".
|
