Posted: May 03, 2000 at 18:51:38: by Tamim
: : : ...why was Thingol caught up in the Nolder's oath? He was not present yet the he fell victom even though he never left Middle Earth.: : Cause he allowed his desire for the Silmarill to get the better of him and therefore became unworthy of its possession. Just like the decendants of Feanor. : : Cheers : :
: : Padster : Feanor was the only mortal who could control it, though, unfortunately, he could not control himself. : Maedhros Mortal?
Would Feänor have been able to touch the Silmarils and the light of the trees after the kinslaying? Personally I think not.
As he is my favourite character I still hope he could have because he made the stones even if the light wasn't his. Please
somebody prove I am wrong.
| 
