Posted: May 07, 2000 at 14:22:08: by Michael Martinez
: : The question of whether or not Frodo failed is by no means an
: : elementary one, nor one that can be answered simply by "doing
: : a little homework.": That was not what I was referring to: It was just that the same
: guy posted a series of questions (including this one) in the
: newsgroups. It was his homework (literally) and he asked for
: our help, without him telling us what it was for. That's all -
: I didn't mean to be provocative. I guess it would have helped if you had made that clear. The question in and of itself is certainly well worth discussing, and if I were feeling better I probably would have joined in the thread myself. Even Tolkien quibbled over whether Frodo's failure was a true failure.
------------------
Xenite.Org: Science Fiction and Fantasy
| 
