: : Well, for one thing, it sounds like you're being influenced
: : by David Day or one of those other miscreants who makes up
: : stuff.

[snip]

: Ah, thanks. I wasn't shure myself if the info i got was
: correct. I read it in The illustrated encyclopedia of ME. Also
: i haven't read all the books, i'm still waiting for history of
: ME.

: But anyway thanks.

You're welcome. As for the ILLUSTRATED ENCYCLOPEDIA, I do believe that is one of Day's travesties. Appreciate it for the pretty pictures, but it has no relevance whatsoever to J.R.R. Tolkien. Day just likes to make up nonsense and pass it off as "Tolkien lore". It bears little resemblance to to anything Tolkien ever actually wrote.
------------------
Xenite.Org: Science Fiction and Fantasy