Posted by John D. on February 17, 2000 at 16:27:30
In Reply to: Re: Who Would You Choose to Direct? posted by Goodgulf on February 17, 2000 at 13:02:05:
: I've seen Kubrick's name mentioned from time to time on wish lists for directors for LOTR. I personally wouldn't want Kubrick (if he were alive) to do it. The film would definitely be Kubrick's LOTR, not Tolkien's. Cinematically I know Kubrick could get the scope and look and feel of Middle-Earth. Any one who has seen Sparticus and the terrific long shots of the Roman legions moving into phalanx positions to battle the "slave" army can't help but be impressed. But I think that Kubrick's ideas and concepts might over-shadow Tolkien's. In other words, the film would have more of Kubrick's stamp on it than Tolkien's. I think that the book needs a director like Jackson, who loves the book and wants to get as much of it on screen as is practical, and is a straight foreward and competent director. Of course Jackson (or any director) will have his own ideas about the book and will put them in the film, we can hope that it will be along the lines of whether or not the Balrog had real wings or just shadows. Or making Arwen a bit more active and included in more scenes to give the romance a more solid base. These are questions we all debate time after time, but in the end it's a matter of personal interpretation. Some will like Jackson's interpretation, others won't. From the photos I've seen, the production looks pretty good. But for many of us the test will be in the details.
I agree with you 100% on Kubrick. As for PJ, I just don't know enough about him to decide whether he has the talent to pull it off. I agree that his attitude and approach seem ideal, but that doesn't mean the movie won't suck. I'd rather have a slightly-askew but entertaining trilogy over a faithfully-adapted but uncompelling one.
Tip: Earlier messages, if they are missing when you click on the links, may be in a lower-numbered archive. Edit the URL in your browser window to change the archive number. Ex. archive_02/ becomes archive_01/.
Tip: Click on the Tolkien and Inklings Forum link to followup to archived messages. You'll need to copy the text from this message and repost it in your new message.
The Tolkien and Inklings Forum is an SF-FANDOM Web site.
