Science fiction and fantasy: Xenite.Org -- Worlds of Imagination on the Web!

The White Council

Re: Status of Minas Ithil

Tolkien and Inklings Discussion

Archive index

Tolkien and Inklings Forum
Middle-earth Mailing List
LoTR movie news
LoTR collectibles
Liv Tyler is Arwen
Elijah Wood is Frodo Baggins
Tolkien Middle-earth at Suite101
LoTR movies forum
All Forums

  Posted by Michael Martinez on March 06, 2000 at 11:22:30
In Reply to: Status of Minas Ithil posted by Foradan on March 06, 2000 at 04:43:36:



: I recently read Isildur and one point in it has made me think : anew. : I used to think that after the War of the Alliance Minas Ithil : was repopulated and remained as it had been. But the Idea that : it was only maintained as a garrisoned fortress, due to : unhealable corruption, makes sense. It had bothered me that : the Ringwraiths were able to conquer Minas Ithil in 2000-2002, : without Sauron and with only a short mention of the incident in : Appendix A. If MI had been a city of like status to Minas : Anor, then during those two years of siege Gondor would have : done its utmost to save the city, and with the power they had : at that time, with a king still in business, they would have : succeeded. But if MI was just an outpost, then it's more : understandable that Gondor wasn't willing to face the terror of : the Nazgūl.

Brian Crawford's story has a lot of logical errors in it and this is one of them. The city of Minas Ithil was isolated, being set way back in a deep valley with only one easy way in or out. All the Nazgul had to do to conquer the city was lay siege to it and patrol the mountains to make sure no one carried supplies over the peaks (and given the description of the terrain Tolkien put into THE RETURN OF THE KING, that simply may not have been possible at all).

If the city was simply garrisoned then why wasn't the garrison withdrawn after the Great Plague forced Gondor to withdraw its border garrisons in Mordor and Enedwaith? That makes no sense.

But, in fact, Anarion was able to retake Minas Ithil during the war, and Isildur stationed two of his sons there to prevent Sauron's escape that way. So the city wasn't in Sauron's hands for very long. There would have been little if any "corruption".

Xenite.Org: Science Fiction and Fantasy


Tip: Earlier messages, if they are missing when you click on the links, may be in a lower-numbered archive. Edit the URL in your browser window to change the archive number. Ex. archive_02/ becomes archive_01/.
Tip: Click on the Tolkien and Inklings Forum link to followup to archived messages. You'll need to copy the text from this message and repost it in your new message.


The Tolkien and Inklings Forum is an SF-FANDOM Web site.

SF-FANDOM is a part of the Xenite.Org network.

Xenite.Org is home to Lord of the Rings movie news. The Tolkien and Inklings Forum is the Web's oldest fan-run forum dedicated to J.R.R. Tolkien.

Xenite.Org has been providing the most comprehensive Lord of the Rings movie news on the Web since February 1998.

Xenite.Org also brings you Xena Online Resources. Xena Online Resources is the Web's largest directory of Hercules and Xena-related content.

The Xenite.Org network is home to more than 100 science fiction and fantasy Web sites.



The Tolkien and Inklings Forum is an independent, moderated forum provided as a courtesy to fans of J.R.R. Tolkien and the Inklings, including C.S. Lewis, Charles Williams, et. al., by Xenite.Org. Please be sure to review our Posting Policy before participating in our forums. This archive is provided as a courtesy of Xenite.Org and in no way implies or imparts any liability or obligation on our part to uphold or maintain the content provided herein. This message and other archived messages from Xenite.Org forums may contain content not necessarily endorsed, reviewed, or approved by Xenite.Org and/or its moderation staff. All opinions expressed in these archives are those of the original posters and do not necessarily represent the views and opinions of Xenite.Org, its owner or owners, moderators, administrators, and/or other volunteer staff or agents. All content is copyright the original poster unless otherwise noted. This page is copyright © 1997-2001 Michael L. Martinez. All rights reserved. No reproduction, electronic or otherwise, may be made without the express permission of the copyright holders, except as occurs in normal browser caching and search engine indexing. You may print one copy of this page for your personal use.